Why Your Nonprofit Needs a Better Newsletter (And How to Fix It)

 

 

A well-crafted nonprofit newsletter is one of the most effective tools for keeping supporters engaged, driving donations, and amplifying your mission. However, many organizations struggle with newsletters that are inconsistent, unfocused, or simply not visually engaging enough to capture attention. If your nonprofit’s newsletter isn’t performing as well as you’d like, it may be time for an upgrade.

 

Common Nonprofit Newsletter Mistakes

• Lack of Clear Purpose – Does your newsletter have a goal? Whether it’s increasing donations, recruiting volunteers, or raising awareness, every edition should serve a specific purpose. Without clarity, your audience may not feel compelled to take action.
• Irregular Sending Schedule – Consistency is key. If you send newsletters sporadically, supporters may forget about your organization. On the other hand, too many emails can lead to subscribers being overwhelmed and eventually unsubscribing. Finding the right balance–whether it’s monthly, biweekly, or quarterly–and staying consistent is the way to keep subscribers.
• Not Visually Engaging – Most people scan emails very quickly. Long blocks of text can overwhelm readers, and lead them to ignore content. Break up your newsletter with headings, bullet points, and eye-catching images.
• Lack of Personalization – Generic greetings like “Dear Supporter” don’t engage readers. Personalizing emails with a recipient’s name or tailored content based on past engagement can improve click-through and engagement rates.
• Weak Calls to Action (CTA) – A nonprofit newsletter should always encourage readers to take the next step, whether that’s donating, signing up for an event, or following you on social media. Use strong, action-oriented language like “Join Us,” ” Donate Today,” or “Show Your Support.”

 

How to Fix Your Nonprofit Newsletter

• A Compelling Subject Line – Your subject line is the hook that determines whether someone will open your email or send it straight to the trash. Keep it concise, engaging, and relevant. For example: “Your Support Can Help Change a Life” or “We Fed XX People Last Month With Your Help”
• Use a Clean, Mobile-Friendly Design – Nearly 60% of readers check emails on their phones, so your newsletter should be mobile-optimized. Use a simple layout, readable fonts, and buttons instead of text for easy finger-clicking.
• Incorporate Storytelling – People connect with stories far more than statistics. Share real-life impact stories about those who have benefited from your nonprofit’s work. Include a powerful quote or testimonial to make it more compelling.
• Segment Your Audience – Not every supporter needs the same content. Donors, volunteers, and general subscribers may have different interests. Segmenting your email list allows you to send tailored content that resonates with each group.
• Track & Optimize – Use email marketing analytics to track open rates, click-through rates, and conversions. If engagement is low, test different subject lines, layouts, or content formats to see what works best for your goals and audience.
• One Last Thing… – Link your newsletter to a well-designed landing page or website. Even the best nonprofit newsletter won’t be effective if it directs readers to a confusing or outdated website. Make sure your site is easy to navigate and easy to donate through and that you are maintaining brand standards across both channels.

If your nonprofit’s newsletter isn’t getting the results you need, we can help. Give us a call at 330-286-0487 or email us at info@mcconnellmarketing.com to see how we can help you improve your communication strategy.

•